Best Stuffed Animals for Babies and Toddlers

Kids & Baby
Enfamil

It’s natural to want to provide your child with a source of comfort that they can have within arm’s reach to help soothe them, so many parents buy best stuffed animals for their children. They can hug them, carry them around, babble to them, and so much more. 

How We Chose Our Ratings

Honesty is important to us, so to come up with our ratings, we performed an extensive examination of customer reviews and testimonials and combined that with any available information about each brand’s reputation. 

Top 10 Best Stuffed Animals for Babies and Toddlers

Baby Gund My First Teddy Bear

Baby GUND My 1st Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal Plush, Tan 10"
  • BABY’S FIRST TEDDY. You never forget your first teddy bear. Make baby’s first friend last a lifetime of hugs and as...
  • GENDER-NEUTRAL COLOR. This My 1st Teddy’s gender-neutral tan color with matching satin accents is a modern and unique...
  • HIGH-QUALITY, SAFE MATERIALS. Like all GUND plush, My 1st Teddy is made from high-quality, huggable plush material for a...

Is there a bigger must-have for your baby’s best stuffed animals collection than the classic teddy bear? You can start small with the 10-inch bear, upgrade to 15 inches, or go overboard with the 18-inch teddy.

This Gund looks like a cute little bear in a light tannish brown that’s great if you want a gender-neutral option. 

Gund,one of the  has been in the stuffed animal business since 1898 which marks it as a brand that produces quality materials. They use premium fabric to ensure the bear is soft, and one that your baby or toddler will love to hug and keep at their side. 

Project Nursery Registry

Also, the bear’s eyes and nose come embroidered so that you don’t have to worry about small pieces that could detach and become a potential choking hazard. It’s also machine-washable so that you can keep it clean, sanitized, and safe for baby. 

Of almost 300 buyers who reviewed their Gund My First Teddy Bear, about 75 percent of them give the stuffed animal five stars. Much of the feedback provided mentioned that the bear is well made, super soft, and perfect for cuddling. 

Also, some grandparents that had bought the same bear for their children over 20 years ago found themselves rebuying it for their grandkids because they knew it was a quality product. 

Aurora World Lil Benny Phant

ebba - Lil Benny Phant - 10" Lil Benny Phant - Grey
  • Measures 9" Tall
  • Super-soft plush and huggable body
  • Endearing facial expression and body position

Aurora World has more than 30 years of experience making the best stuffed animals. Their Lil Benny Phant, one of the best stuffed animals, is an adorable, super soft, and plush baby elephant.

You can choose from grey, mint, or pink. He (or she) is sitting with a cute expression on his face and with his “arms” tucked between his legs. The toy is about nine inches tall. 

Benny Phant makes an effort to prevent the button eyes from detaching and becoming a safety hazard by doing more than just gluing them on and providing backing through the fabric. 

Over 1,000 customers bought the Aurora World Lil Benny Phant, and over 90 percent of them gave the elephant five stars because it was so soft and huggable.

A lot of people shared that they thought because the best stuffed animals costs about $10 to $13, depending on the color, that the toy would be cheap, but they were pleasantly surprised to see it was excellent quality. 

Also, it is machine washable, but buyers suggest using cold water and the delicate cycle to ensure durability. 

brown teddy bear

Image via Pixabay

 Plush Monkey Ollie Bedtime Originals

Bedtime Originals Plush Monkey Ollie, Brown
  • Curly Tails Plush Monkey Ollie is 8" high soft and cuddly
  • 2 tone plush
  • Soft stitched eyes and mouth

There’s something about cute little monkeys that draws kids to them; look at Curious George.

Well, Bedtime Originals knows how magnetic an adorable monkey can be, so they made Ollie, a two-tone monkey that has a chocolate brown body and light tan face, ears, and feet. It also has a tail that curls at the end. 

Ollie comes completely stitched, so you don’t have to worry about any parts coming off from the animal and posing a safety threat for your little one.

The monkey is about eight inches in height, can be washed in the machine using the delicate cycle, and put in the dryer with the tumble dry low setting. 

Almost 500 people who purchased Ollie shared a review, and nearly 85 percent of buyers gave him five stars with another 8 percent rating him with four stars. Customers say the monkey is a bit of a steal with the $7 price tag.  

Parents and grandparents say it’s adorable, soft, durable when handled as the instructions say, holds up to being dragged by the tail by toddlers and gnawed on by babies. Poor guy!

Harry the Bunny

Bunny of The Year Baby First TV: Harry The Bunny Soft Plush Toy -...
  • YOUR CHILD WILL FALL IN BUNNY LOVE - Harry the Bunny Plush Toy, star of the popular BabyFirstTV series, makes a great...
  • THIS CHEERFUL BUNNY IS THE PERFECT INFANT TOY FOR THE CAR SEAT OR STROLLER - Your child will fall in love with this...
  • PERFECT BEDTIME & TRAVEL BUDDY FOR BABIES & TODDLERS - This babys stuffed animal is sure to make them giggle and smile....

If you have access to the Baby First channel, then chances are you’re familiar with Harry the Bunny. Baby First knows babies and toddlers like their friendly, helpful rabbit that gets his fair share of airtime on the network.

He measures about 15 inches in height, so it is a substantially sized toy which might not be suited for smaller babies. 

The adorable Harry plush is wearing a blue sweater and red overalls with a carrot on the front. If your baby or toddler enjoys playing with their stuffed animal, his light beige bunny fur could end up being a magnet for stains, so it’s a good thing he’s machine-washable.

All the body parts are embroidered, so you don’t have to worry about your child possibly eyes or the nose off and putting it in their mouth.  

About 400 parents who purchased Harry the Bunny provided feedback on their stuffed, animal and the majority rated it with five stars. Many customers say that their child loves the Harry the Bunny character and the plush looks just like the one on television.

Some buyers caution that the toy is a bit of a lint-magnet and that if you do wash it, you should use the delicate cycle. 

Taggies Oodles Owl Character Blanket

Taggies Oodles Owl Character Blanket
  • Taggies Oodles Owl Character Blanket
  • Blanket is 17x17 Inches, fully lined and features embroidered accents.
  • Oodles Owl, A soft pink corduroy with an embroidered face sits on top a pink, green and blue blanket with Patented...

A cute stuffed animal attached to a soft cuddly blanket made with a rainbow of colors? That pretty much guarantees that your baby will want to take the Taggies Oodles Owl Character Blanket everywhere with them.

The Oodles Owl has plush pink corduroy with an embroidered face, and it sits on the top of a multi-colored blanket with a multitude of ribbon loops for babies to play with and grab. 

Taggies is a line made by Mary Meyer, a company that has been making toys since 1933 so you’ll be buying from a manufacturer that has a long history of producing quality stuffed animals for children.

The blanket is about 17 inches by 17 inches, has embroidered accents, and is fully lined for added softness.  

To wash the blanket, you should use a mesh laundry bag with the gentle cycle and let it air dry. 

Nearly all of the reviews for the Taggies Oodles Owl Character Blanket were either four or five stars. Parents say children as small as six months and as big as five years old love the stuffed animal and blanket.

Buyers noted that it’s very soft, the colors are bright and eye-catching, and the stitching is superb. Babies practice their pincer skills exploring the attached loops and textures.  

The owl is the perfect size for hugging, and the blanket’s length makes it easier for babies to cuddle the stuffed animal. 

Squishmallow 8-inch Cat

Kelly Toy 8" Squishmallow - Cam Cat
  • Cameron "Cam" the Cat
  • Kelly Toy has created a line of loveable buddies made from super soft marshmallow-like texture and polyester
  • Easily washable and dryable

The Squishmallow Cat, one of the best stuffed animals, looks like a cat, sort of. It’s cute with whiskers and a bit of calico coloring, with one black ear, one orange ear, and a pale face. 

But, that’s where the similarities end because this cat has a shape similar to marshmallow, so it’s soft and squishy. 

The stuffing has a combination of spandex and polyester foam that is like memory foam, so the plush is designed to be squished and then springs back.

Babies and toddlers can have endless hours of fun hugging and putting the Squishmallow through its paces and watching it return to its original shape.

If cats are not your thing, you can choose from other Squishmallow animals like a: 

  • Fox
  • Panda
  • Unicorn

You can buy the Squishmallow Cat in the eight-inch size for about $10, or if you’d like to get a larger one for your toddler, the 13-inch cat is $23. This plush is machine-washable, and you can use the tumble dry setting in the dryer. 

About 80 percent of people who bought the Squishmallow Cat gave it five stars and said it was very soft, well made, and super fun for kids. Parents even admitted to stealing the Squishmallow sometimes because it feels like a stress ball.

 group of teddy bear

Image via Pixabay

Gund Baby Animated Flappy the Elephant

Baby GUND Animated Flappy the Elephant Stuffed Animal Plush, Gray, 12"
  • FLAPPY THE ELEPHANT: Animated plush Flappy the Elephant by Baby GUND is an adorable singing animated plush with two...
  • INTERACTIVE PLAY: Flappy comes to life at the push of a button! As baby plays and listens, Flappy's ears flap in time to...
  • THE PERFECT GIFT: Our plush dolls, teddy bears & stuffed animals make perfect gifts for birthdays, baby showers,...

The Gund Baby Animated Flappy the Elephant is Amazon’s number one best seller in the stuffed animal department racking up over 2,700 customer reviews.

With its long history of making quality toys since 1898, it’s no surprise to find more than one Gund product in a roundup of the best stuffed animals. 

The loveable Flappy stands at about 12 inches tall, is light grey, and super soft. One of his legs is marked “sing” and the other “play” so that your child can interact with the toy.

Pressing “play” launches a round of peek-a-boo and makes Flappy’s upright ears flop down to cover his eyes. Pushing “sing” makes the elephant sing the song “Do Your Ears Hang Low” while his ears flap about to entertain your little one.

Due to needing three AA batteries to power the toy, Flappy is not machine-washable, but you should be able to clean his exterior with a moist cloth.  

About 90 percent of people who bought Gund’s Animated Baby Elephant gave it a five-star rating with many parents and grandparents head over heels with Flappy’s adorableness.

Many say that it is guaranteed to make you and your child smile and that the toy is very soft and well made. One downside is that it doesn’t have volume control and a few people thought it was a little loud.

Cloud B Sleep Sheep

Cloud b Sleep Sheep On The Go Travel Sound Soother
  • WHITE NOISE: Four soothing sound options including gentle stream, spring showers, ocean surf and whale songs.
  • PORTABLE: Travel size easily fits in diaper bag or carry on luggage.
  • EASY: Hook and Loop Fastener For Attachment To Baby’s Crib, Strollers Or Car Seat

This adorable little white sheep is more than just precious. It also plays sounds to help your baby fall asleep. It comes with two AA batteries, and you can choose from eight peaceful sounds to help lull your little one including: 

  • Ocean waves
  • Heartbeat
  • “Twinkle Twinkle”

You can set a timer with an automatic shutoff after two different time settings so that Sleep Sheep can play sounds for either 23 or 45 minutes. 

Since you shouldn’t leave stuffed animals in the crib with your baby, the Sleep Sheep comes with a Velcro strap which lets you attach it to the bars of the crib as well as stroller and car seat handles. 

If your little lamb gets dirty, you can wash it in the machine but be sure to remove the sound device before you get it wet.

The sheep also has three white noise settings which can help soothe baby to sleep. This little stuffed animal is so popular that it has won awards like the National Parenting Council’s Seal of Approval. 

Over 1,400 parents provided feedback on their Sleep Sheep purchase, and about 80 percent gave it a four or five-star rating. Many buyers vouch for the stuffed animal’s ability to help put babies and even toddlers to sleep.

Other positive reviews liked how soft the plush is and the Velcro attachment that allows you to use it around the crib, but not directly in it with the baby. 

2 teddy bear sitting in sofa

Image via Pixabay

MerryMakers Pete the Cat

MerryMakers Pete the Cat Plush Doll, 14.5-Inch
  • Pete the Cat plush doll
  • Based on the bestselling 'Pete the Cat' series created by James Dean
  • Safe for all ages, perfect for ages 2 and up

If you’ve been reading to your baby or toddler, chances are you might have come across Pete the Cat. He’s a cool cat with a positive vibe who likes to help out and has more than 15 million books out there. 

A bit of a celebrity, Pete the Cat books have been on the New York Times bestseller list for 200 weeks total. 

Although this stuffed toy is safe for all ages, it’s best for kids who are at least two years old since at around 14 inches long. He’s a little big for infants. 

This blue cat has one red shoe, one blue shoe, a serene expression, and wears his heart for all to see. Toddlers will enjoy curling his long tail and hugging this super soft plush.

Next time you pull out a Pete the Cat book, Pete can come along to hear about his adventures. 

Over 87 percent of close to 1,000 customers rated this Pete the Cat toy with five stars. Parents said they liked the quality, softness, and how well the animal holds up if you have to wash it in the machine multiple times. 

However, there were a few buyers who had issues with the back seam opening. It was mentioned in a fair share of the negative reviews, so it’s worth keeping in mind. 

Baby Einstein Octoplush Toy

Baby Einstein Octoplush Musical Plush Toy, Ages 3 months +
  • Baby can cuddle up to new colors and music
  • Huggable & soft to touch for tactile development
  • Discover the colors in English, Spanish and French

When you’re thinking of buying best stuffed animals for babies and toddlers, an octopus might not be the first animal that comes to mind, but Baby Einstein’s Octoplush Toy could get you to think outside the box. 

This charming blue octopus is more than a cuddly, stuffed animal. First, its bright blue color is sure to snag your child’s attention.

Second, with eight legs to grab, kids will have fun with the variety of options and babies can practice developing their motor skills and pincer grasp. 

But the legs are more than appendages. Each leg has an image embroidered on it, and with a light squeeze, the octopus will tell you what color the picture is and play a snippet of classical music.

Baby Einstein has a reputation for over 20 years of making toys that help babies learn too so this toy teaches the colors in Spanish, French, and English. If you squeeze the Ocotoplush’s head, it will play more music. 

This is about seven inches in height, costs around $10, and requires two AA batteries that you’ll have to buy separately.  

Over 1,500 people have shared their thoughts on their Baby Einstein Octoplush Toy, and about 70 percent gave it five stars with another 15 giving it four stars.

A lot of buyers said kids ranging in age from three months to three years old enjoy playing with the Octoplush. Children enjoy the clear sounds made by the octopus and pressing the different arms to elicit the different responses. 

Buyer’s Guide

teddy  bear with camera

Image via Pixabay

When trying to find the best stuffed animals for babies and toddlers, it’s easy to be overwhelmed by the adorable options. However, there are a few things to keep in mind before you make your selection.

It’s best to avoid any stuffed animals that might have sewn on parts like eyes, noses, or buttons that could pose possible choking hazards for small children.

Also, a little monkey or bear that rattles when you shake it could be super cute, but you might want to avoid rattling toys because if the beads were to leak out, they could be dangerous too.

One last thing to keep an eye out for is stuffed animals that have plastic parts. Some toys that contained plastic and came from China had phthalates which are chemicals that could pose certain health risks. 

Featured Image via Pixabay

Rate This Post

Loading...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *